Six coins of gold and silver of equal weights are melted and new coins are cast. The ratio of gold and silver in one of the coins is $2 : 1$, in another two coins $3 : 5$ and $7 : 5$ in the remaining coins. What will be the ratio between gold and silver respectively in the new coins? (R.R.B., 2006)
Aptitude
Alligation or Mixture
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A$1 : 1$
-
B$12 : 11$
-
C$42 : 25$
-
D$19 : 17$
Answer
Correct Answer: $19 : 17$
Explanation
### Concept & Weighted Mixtures
When combining items of equal total volumes but different internal ratios and differing quantities (weights), determine a unified weight scale using the LCM of the ratio sums, then aggregate the components based on the number of items in each group.
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Given:**
- Total number of coins = $6$ (all equal weight).
- Group 1: $1$ coin with Gold:Silver = $2 : 1$ (Sum of parts = $3$)
- Group 2: $2$ coins with Gold:Silver = $3 : 5$ (Sum of parts = $8$)
- Group 3: Remaining coins = $6 - 1 - 2 = 3$ coins with Gold:Silver = $7 : 5$ (Sum of parts = $12$)
* **Calculation:**
1. Find the LCM of the ratio sums ($3, 8, 12$) to avoid fractions. The LCM is $24$. Let the weight of one coin be $24$ units.
2. Calculate the components for Group 1 ($1$ coin):
- Gold = $\frac{2}{3} \times 24 = 16$ units
- Silver = $\frac{1}{3} \times 24 = 8$ units
- Total from Group 1 = $16$ Gold, $8$ Silver.
3. Calculate the components for Group 2 ($2$ coins):
- Gold per coin = $\frac{3}{8} \times 24 = 9$ units. Total Gold for $2$ coins = $9 \times 2 = 18$ units.
- Silver per coin = $\frac{5}{8} \times 24 = 15$ units. Total Silver for $2$ coins = $15 \times 2 = 30$ units.
4. Calculate the components for Group 3 ($3$ coins):
- Gold per coin = $\frac{7}{12} \times 24 = 14$ units. Total Gold for $3$ coins = $14 \times 3 = 42$ units.
- Silver per coin = $\frac{5}{12} \times 24 = 10$ units. Total Silver for $3$ coins = $10 \times 3 = 30$ units.
5. Aggregate the total amounts for the new cast coins:
- Total Gold = $16 + 18 + 42 = 76$ units.
- Total Silver = $8 + 30 + 30 = 68$ units.
6. The final ratio of Gold to Silver is $76 : 68$.
7. Simplifying the ratio by dividing by $4$ yields $19 : 17$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Scale up each ratio directly using multipliers to reach the LCM of $24$, then multiply by the number of coins.
Base scaling: $2:1 \rightarrow 16:8$. $3:5 \rightarrow 9:15$. $7:5 \rightarrow 14:10$.
Multiply by coin counts:
$1 \times (16:8) \rightarrow 16 : 8$
$2 \times (9:15) \rightarrow 18 : 30$
$3 \times (14:10) \rightarrow 42 : 30$
Sum: $(16+18+42) : (8+30+30) = 76 : 68 = 19 : 17$.
### Common Pitfall
A frequent error is calculating the composition for a single coin of each type and just adding those together ($16+9+14 : 8+15+10$), failing to account for the fact that there are multiple coins of the second and third types.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **$19 : 17$**.