Self-cleansing velocity criterion: When a sewer is designed for self-cleansing velocity, what should happen at the invert (bottom) of the conduit under design flow?
-
AThe bottom is silted
-
BThe bottom is scoured continuously
-
CBoth silting and scouring occur simultaneously
-
DNeither silting nor scouring occurs at the bottom
-
EOnly gross solids move while fines deposit
Answer
Correct Answer: Neither silting nor scouring occurs at the bottom
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Self-cleansing velocity is the minimum velocity (or shear stress) in a sewer that prevents deposition of suspended and bed materials while avoiding damage to the pipe. It is a key check for minimum-flow conditions in sanitary and combined systems.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Design target is to prevent deposition during low flows.
- Pipe material should not be eroded by routine operation.
- Velocity or shear stress is set based on sediment characteristics.
Concept / Approach:At self-cleansing velocity, the hydraulic forces at the invert are just adequate to keep solids from settling; they are not so high as to scour the pipe wall or protective coatings. Thus, the desired condition is absence of both silting and scouring under design flow.
Step-by-Step Reasoning:Set a threshold for bed shear/velocity based on sediment size and specific gravity.Check velocity at minimum flow; ensure it meets or exceeds this threshold.Confirm that the selected velocity is still below erosive limits for the pipe material.
Verification / Alternative check:Standards often recommend minimum velocities around 0.6–0.75 m/s for sanitary sewers (varies by code, sediment load, and slope), specifically to maintain self-cleansing without erosion.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Silting or continuous scouring indicates the velocity is too low or too high, respectively.Simultaneous silting and scouring contradicts a stable operating point.Selective movement of only gross solids does not guarantee a clean invert.
Common Pitfalls:
- Using a single velocity value irrespective of sediment characteristics.
- Ignoring pipe roughness and slope, which affect shear stress.
Final Answer:Neither silting nor scouring occurs at the bottom