Surface loading terminology: The ratio of design discharge to the plan surface area of a sedimentation tank is called what?
-
ASurface loading
-
BOverflow rate
-
COverflow velocity
-
DAll of these
-
EDetention coefficient
Answer
Correct Answer: All of these
Explanation
Introduction / Context:In clarifier design, the parameter Q/A (where A is the plan surface area) is fundamental. It appears under various interchangeable names in the literature, and recognizing this equivalence helps in reading diverse references and codes.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Q = design flow.
- A = plan surface area (length × width).
- Ideal clarification theory where removal is related to surface overflow.
Concept / Approach:Q/A is commonly termed surface loading rate (SLR), overflow rate, or overflow velocity. Under ideal conditions, a particle with settling velocity equal to or greater than Q/A will be removed. These terms are synonymous in most water and wastewater design texts.
Step-by-Step Reasoning:Compute Q/A as a design check.Use it to compare with settling velocities of particle classes.Recognize that different sources may label it as surface loading, overflow rate, or overflow velocity.
Verification / Alternative check:Multiple handbooks and standards cross-reference these terms, confirming their equivalence for conventional basins.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Each of (a), (b), and (c) is correct; selecting only one is incomplete.Detention coefficient is not a standard name for Q/A.
Common Pitfalls:
- Mistaking Q/A for detention time; detention is V/Q and involves depth.
- Using SLR without considering short-circuiting and flocculation behavior.
Final Answer:All of these