A boat takes a total of 3 hours to travel from place M to N downstream and then back from N to M upstream. If the boat’s speed in still water is 4 km/h, what is the distance MN? (Assume stream speed is unknown.)

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Data inadequate

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Data adequacy problems ask whether the given information uniquely determines the answer. Here, we have total round-trip time and still-water speed, but the stream speed is not provided.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Total time T = 3 h
  • Still-water speed b = 4 km/h
  • Unknown current c
  • Distance each way = d km


Concept / Approach:
The time equation is T = d/(b + c) + d/(b − c). Without c, multiple (d, c) pairs can satisfy the same T; therefore, d is not uniquely determined.


Step-by-Step Reasoning:

3 = d/(4 + c) + d/(4 − c)For different positive c values < 4, one can solve for different d values to satisfy the same total time.


Verification / Alternative check:
Try c = 1 km/h: then 3 = d/5 + d/3 ⇒ 3 = ( (3d + 5d) / 15 ) ⇒ d = 45/8 = 5.625 km. Try c = 0.5 km/h: 3 = d/4.5 + d/3.5, leading to a different d. Hence non-unique.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Any specific distance assumes a particular c; since c is not given, those values are not guaranteed.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming c = 0 or guessing c. A unique distance requires either c or one additional relation.


Final Answer:
Data inadequate.

More Questions from Boats and Streams

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion