Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: 8 : 3
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This problem compares times to travel the same distance upstream and downstream to extract the speeds in still water and current via ratios.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
Upstream speed = b - c; downstream speed = b + c. Since D is the same, ratios of speeds equal inverse ratios of times: (b - c)/(b + c) = Td/Tu.
Step-by-Step Solution:
(b - c)/(b + c) = 4 / 8.8 = 5 / 11
11(b - c) = 5(b + c)
11b - 11c = 5b + 5c ⇒ 6b = 16c ⇒ b/c = 16/6 = 8/3
Verification / Alternative check:
Any numbers with b : c = 8 : 3 (for example b = 8, c = 3) satisfy (b - c)/(b + c) = 5/11, which matches 4/8.8.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
2 : 1 and 3 : 2 do not produce 5/11 on substitution. 'Couldn't be determined' is wrong because the two times are sufficient to determine the ratio uniquely.
Common Pitfalls:
Using Tu/Td instead of Td/Tu; forgetting to convert minutes to hours; cancelling the distance incorrectly.
Final Answer:
8 : 3
Discussion & Comments