Statement & Argument — Should commercial activity be permitted in residential areas? Arguments: I. No, it impairs healthy development and living conditions of residents. II. Yes, it contributes to economic development and is a major economic activity.
Verbal Reasoning
Statement and Argument
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
Aif only argument I is strong.
-
Bif only argument II is strong.
-
CIf either I or II is strong.
-
Dif neither I nor II is strong; and
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: If either I or II is strong.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Zoning balances livability against economic vibrancy. Both sides can be strong if they address core planning objectives.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Residential well-being can be harmed by noise, traffic, and pollution from commercial uses.
- Mixed-use, when planned, may boost local economies and convenience.
Concept / Approach:Argument I is strong because it focuses on resident health and livability. Argument II is strong because it references economic benefits. Since both are policy-relevant but in tension, either argument is strong.
Final Answer:Either Argument I or II is strong.