Instrumentation classification: Which of the following is not a composition-measuring instrument used for gas or liquid analysis?
-
AThermal conductivity cell
-
BMass spectrometer
-
CPolarograph
-
DHot wire anemometer
Answer
Correct Answer: Hot wire anemometer
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Process analyzers measure composition to ensure quality, safety, and control. Common technologies include thermal conductivity, mass spectrometry, electrochemical methods, and spectroscopies. Distinguishing true composition analyzers from flow/velocity instruments avoids misapplication.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- We are considering instruments commonly used in process or lab environments.
- “Composition-measuring” means reporting concentration or species identity/ratio.
- All options are real instruments but have different primary functions.
Concept / Approach:A thermal conductivity cell measures bulk gas composition by relating conductivity to species fractions (e.g., binary mixtures like H2/N2). A mass spectrometer separates ions by mass-to-charge, providing highly resolved composition. A polarograph (voltammetry) measures current–potential behavior to quantify electroactive species. A hot wire anemometer, however, measures fluid velocity by heat transfer from a heated wire; it does not directly report chemical composition.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Classify each instrument by its measurement principle.Identify which does not produce composition information.Select “Hot wire anemometer.”Verification / Alternative check:Manufacturer datasheets and textbooks list hot wire anemometers under velocity/flow diagnostics, not analyzers.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Thermal conductivity cell: classic binary gas analyzer.Mass spectrometer: definitive multi-component analyzer.Polarograph: electroanalytical concentration measurement of redox-active species.Common Pitfalls:Assuming any “electrical output” device measures composition; many sensors output signals for non-compositional variables like flow or temperature.
Final Answer:Hot wire anemometer