Sub-zero temperature measurement: Which instrument from the list is generally not used for measuring temperatures below 0 °C (sub-zero work) under typical laboratory conditions?
-
APlatinum resistance thermometer
-
BMercury-in-glass thermometer
-
CVapor-pressure thermometer
-
DRadiation pyrometer
Answer
Correct Answer: Mercury-in-glass thermometer
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Choosing the right temperature sensor for sub-zero work depends on the sensor’s physical limitations and accuracy. While several devices function well below 0 °C, mercury-in-glass thermometers are constrained by the freezing point of mercury and are therefore unsuitable without special modifications.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Temperature to be measured is below 0 °C.
- Standard, unpressurized mercury thermometers.
- Standard lab alternatives such as platinum resistance thermometers (PRTs), vapor-pressure thermometers, and non-contact methods are available.
Concept / Approach:Mercury freezes at about −38.8 °C, and even near 0 to −10 °C mercury thermometers can suffer from column separation, wetting issues, and slow response. For reliable sub-zero measurements, PRTs (e.g., Pt100) remain accurate down to −200 °C; vapor-pressure thermometers with appropriate fluids function below 0 °C; radiation pyrometers can read cold surfaces if emissivity is known, though they are less common for low temperatures due to low radiance.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Assess each instrument’s low-temperature capability.Recognize mercury limitations and risks below 0 °C.Select mercury-in-glass as the option generally not used for sub-zero temperatures.Verification / Alternative check:Instrument datasheets confirm PRT operation to deep sub-zero temperatures; many vapor-pressure devices use propane or other fluids for low ranges.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Platinum resistance thermometer: excellent precision below 0 °C.Vapor-pressure thermometer: selection of fill fluid allows sub-zero operation.Radiation pyrometer: can measure cold surfaces with proper calibration and emissivity knowledge.Common Pitfalls:Ignoring self-heating in PRTs or emissivity errors in pyrometry; always calibrate and account for environmental factors.
Final Answer:Mercury-in-glass thermometer