Drinking-water microbiology: Which of the following water-borne diseases are caused by non-pathogenic bacteria?
-
ACholera
-
BTyphoid fever
-
CInfectious (viral) hepatitis
-
DNone of these.
-
EAll of these.
Answer
Correct Answer: None of these.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Water-borne diseases result from ingestion of water contaminated with pathogenic organisms (disease-causing microbes). Understanding which agents are pathogenic is essential for public-health protection, disinfection design, and monitoring programs.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- “Non-pathogenic bacteria” by definition do not cause disease.
- Cholera is caused by Vibrio cholerae (pathogenic bacteria).
- Typhoid fever is caused by Salmonella Typhi (pathogenic bacteria).
- Infectious hepatitis (commonly Hepatitis A or E) is caused by viruses, not non-pathogenic bacteria.
Concept / Approach:Clarify terminology: pathogenic vs non-pathogenic organisms. Relate each listed disease to its causative agent. If any disease is caused by pathogens (bacteria or viruses), it cannot be attributed to non-pathogenic bacteria.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify cholera → bacterial and pathogenic → excludes non-pathogenic cause.Identify typhoid → bacterial and pathogenic → excludes non-pathogenic cause.Identify infectious hepatitis → viral pathogen, not bacterial.Therefore, none of the listed diseases is caused by non-pathogenic bacteria.Verification / Alternative check:Public-health references list Vibrio cholerae and Salmonella Typhi among notifiable pathogens; Hepatitis A/E are enteric viruses controlled by source protection and disinfection.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Cholera and typhoid are explicitly caused by pathogenic bacteria.
- Infectious hepatitis is viral, not bacterial.
- “All of these” contradicts definitions; “None of these” is consistent with causation.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing “indicator bacteria” (e.g., coliforms) with pathogens; assuming all water-borne illnesses are bacterial; overlooking viruses and protozoa in control strategies.
Final Answer:None of these.