Cooling tower performance: To what theoretical limit can circulating water be cooled in a standard evaporative cooling tower operating with ambient air?
-
ADew point temperature of air
-
BWet-bulb temperature of air
-
CDry-bulb temperature of air
-
DAmbient air temperature (unspecified)
Answer
Correct Answer: Wet-bulb temperature of air
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Cooling towers reject heat by partial evaporation of water into an airstream. Understanding the limiting cold-water temperature is essential for plant performance estimates and chiller selection.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Evaporative cooling tower operating at near-atmospheric pressure.
- Air–water contact allows heat and mass transfer (sensible and latent).
- Negligible heat sources other than process heat load.
Concept / Approach:The fundamental limit is the entering air wet-bulb temperature (WBT). In an ideal tower with infinite size and perfect contact, the cooled water approaches the WBT asymptotically; it cannot be cooled below the WBT because equilibrium between water temperature and the adiabatic saturation temperature of the air defines the driving potential.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Define approach: approach = cold-water temperature − entering air wet-bulb temperature.In the ideal limit, approach → 0, so cold water → WBT.Therefore, the minimum achievable cold-water temperature equals the entering air wet-bulb temperature.Verification / Alternative check:Psychrometric analysis: adiabatic saturation process aligns with wet-bulb lines; at equilibrium, water temperature equals the air’s adiabatic saturation (wet-bulb) temperature.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Dew point: lower than WBT only at very dry conditions; towers cannot reach dew point by evaporative contact.
- Dry-bulb: generally higher than WBT; not the limiting temperature in evaporative cooling.
- “Ambient air temperature” is ambiguous and often equals dry bulb; it is not the limit.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing dew point with wet bulb; dew point governs condensation processes, not evaporative cooling limits.
Final Answer:Wet-bulb temperature of air