More Questions from Steam Boilers and Engines

Boilers with and without forced circulation In which of the following boilers does forced circulation of water not take place?

Mechanical Engineering Steam Boilers and Engines Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    La-Mont boiler
  • B
    Lancashire boiler
  • C
    Velox boiler
  • D
    Benson boiler
  • E
    Once-through supercritical boiler

Answer

Correct Answer: Lancashire boiler

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Boiler circulation refers to how water/steam moves through heated circuits. Modern high-pressure water-tube designs often employ forced circulation using pumps or gas-dynamic effects, whereas classic shell-type fire-tube boilers rely on natural convection.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • La-Mont and Velox are water-tube designs with explicit circulation enhancement.
  • Benson and once-through supercritical designs use pumped flow through evaporator tubes.
  • Lancashire is a large shell fire-tube boiler.

Concept / Approach:La-Mont employs an external circulating pump to force water through evaporator tubes. Velox uses high-velocity gas flow and pressure to enhance heat transfer and circulation. Benson/once-through boilers pump feedwater through the heating circuit without a steam drum—flow is definitely forced. Lancashire boilers, however, are fire-tube shells with a big water space where circulation is natural (density differences) rather than pump-driven.

Step-by-Step Solution:Identify water-tube forced-circulation examples: La-Mont, Velox, Benson.Identify the outlier: Lancashire (fire-tube) with natural circulation.Therefore, forced circulation does not occur in Lancashire boilers.

Verification / Alternative check:Design schematics show no circulation pump in Lancashire; modern high-pressure units always show pumps driving flow through small-diameter tubes.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:All others listed apply forced or once-through circulation; selecting them would contradict their defining features.

Common Pitfalls:Assuming “once-through” implies natural circulation; it actually relies on feed pumps for flow through the circuit.

Final Answer:Lancashire boiler

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion