Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Only argument I is strong
Explanation:
Given data
Concept/Approach (economic function vs. blanket dismissal)
Advertising plays roles in informing consumers, differentiating products, and stimulating competition; calling it mere 'waste' is an overgeneralisation.
Step-by-Step evaluation
1) Argument I: Posits a systemic role consistent with market economies ⇒ strong.2) Argument II: Ignores informational and competitive benefits; blanket 'waste' claim ⇒ weak.
Verification/Alternative
While some ads may be excessive, the institution of advertising as such fulfills economic functions.
Common pitfalls
Equating instances of excess with the uselessness of the entire activity.
Final Answer
Only argument I is strong.
Discussion & Comments