Who prepares early-stage (order-of-magnitude / preliminary / conceptual) estimates? Select the party most commonly responsible for feasibility-level and budget-level estimates in building projects.
-
AArchitect/engineer
-
BConstruction manager
-
COwner (client) alone
-
DConstruction manager (duplicate)
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: Architect/engineer
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Early-stage estimates guide feasibility and funding decisions when design information is limited. These are order-of-magnitude and conceptual budgets that rely on parametric data, historical cost indices, and schematic take-offs. Assigning responsibility clarifies who should supply the assumptions behind the numbers.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Project is at concept/feasibility or schematic stage.
- Limited drawings; heavy reliance on benchmarks and unit rates.
- Multiple parties can contribute, but one typically leads.
Concept / Approach:In typical building projects, the architect/engineer (A/E) prepares preliminary and conceptual estimates tied to the evolving design, often validated by a quantity surveyor or cost consultant. A construction manager may also produce estimates in CM-at-risk or early contractor involvement models, but in traditional delivery, the A/E leads at this stage in coordination with the owner.
Step-by-Step Solution:Identify which role has design custody and access to scope assumptions at concept level: the A/E.Acknowledge that CMs contribute when engaged early, but question expects the conventional answer.Select “Architect/engineer”.
Verification / Alternative check:Standard practice guides indicate the A/E or a cost consultant under the A/E team prepares Class 4–5 estimates (conceptual), with owner approvals following.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Construction manager: feasible under certain delivery methods, but not universally the default.Owner alone: lacks the technical detail and benchmarks without A/E support.None of these: incorrect because A/E is a recognized preparer.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming the bidder's detailed estimate (post-design) is the same as conceptual estimates.
- Ignoring the role of independent cost consultants engaged by the A/E.
Final Answer:Architect/engineer