Peak runoff rate from a design storm using a distribution graph An intense storm of uniform intensity 7.5 cm/h lasts 60 minutes over a basin of area 500 hectares. Average infiltration capacity during the storm is 1.5 cm/h. Using a 10-minute peak percentage of 16% from the basin’s distribution graph, estimate the maximum runoff rate (cumecs).
-
A40 cumecs
-
B60 cumecs
-
C80 cumecs
-
D100 cumecs
-
E120 cumecs
Answer
Correct Answer: 80 cumecs
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Design peak discharge can be estimated from total direct-runoff volume combined with a dimensionless distribution graph (e.g., Bernard-type), which gives the percentage of total runoff occurring in the most intense block (here, the 10-minute peak).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Storm intensity i = 7.5 cm/h for 60 minutes.
- Average infiltration capacity f = 1.5 cm/h.
- Basin area A = 500 ha.
- 10-minute peak percentage = 16% of total runoff volume.
Concept / Approach:Total direct runoff depth equals rainfall depth minus losses by infiltration during the same duration. The peak 10-minute discharge equals the fraction of total runoff volume assigned to the 10-minute peak, divided by 600 seconds.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Compute rainfall excess intensity: i_e = i − f = 7.5 − 1.5 = 6.0 cm/h.Storm duration = 1 h ⇒ runoff depth D_e = 6.0 cm = 0.06 m.Convert area: 500 ha = 5,000,000 m².Total runoff volume V = A * D_e = 5,000,000 * 0.06 = 300,000 m³.Peak 10-min volume = 0.16 * V = 0.16 * 300,000 = 48,000 m³.Peak discharge Q_p = 48,000 m³ / 600 s = 80 m³/s.Verification / Alternative check:Average discharge over the full hour is V / 3600 ≈ 83.3 m³/s. A 10-min peak at 80 m³/s is reasonable given the distribution shape and chosen peak percentage.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 40 and 60 m³/s underestimate the computed peak given the 16% allocation.
- 100 and 120 m³/s exceed the physically consistent result from the stated distribution percentage.
Common Pitfalls:Mixing cm and m or hectares and km²; misapplying the peak percentage to intensity rather than to total runoff volume; using 10 minutes as 10 seconds by mistake.
Final Answer:80 cumecs