Compare average dc output of half-wave versus full-wave (M–2) controlled rectifiers with a resistive load: relation between Vdc1 (half-wave) and Vdc2 (full-wave) for any firing angle α.
-
AVdc1 = 0.5 Vdc2 for all firing angles
-
BVdc1 = Vdc2 for all firing angles
-
CVdc1 ≤ 0.5 Vdc2 for all firing angles
-
DVdc1 ≥ 0.5 Vdc2 for all firing angles
-
EVdc1 = 2 Vdc2 for α = 0 only
Answer
Correct Answer: Vdc1 = 0.5 Vdc2 for all firing angles
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Average output voltage of phase-controlled rectifiers depends on firing angle and whether one or two half-cycles are used. Full-wave topologies deliver pulses twice per cycle, doubling the average (for the same Vm and α) relative to half-wave circuits.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Resistive load.
- Half-wave controlled rectifier (single thyristor): Vdc1 formula.
- Full-wave controlled rectifier (M–2): Vdc2 formula.
Concept / Approach:
Standard results: For half-wave controlled rectifier, Vdc1 = (Vm / 2π) (1 + cos α). For the full-wave (M–2), Vdc2 = (Vm / π) (1 + cos α). Therefore Vdc1 = 0.5 * Vdc2 for any α in [0, π].
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write Vdc1 = (Vm / 2π) (1 + cos α).Write Vdc2 = (Vm / π) (1 + cos α).Divide: Vdc1 / Vdc2 = 1/2 ⇒ Vdc1 = 0.5 Vdc2 (independent of α).Verification / Alternative check:
At α = 0, Vdc1 = Vm/π, Vdc2 = 2Vm/π ⇒ ratio 0.5. At α = π/2, both reduce by the same factor, maintaining the 0.5 ratio.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Equality or inequalities contradict the established factor-of-two difference due to pulse repetition rate.
- Dependence on α cancelling in the ratio is overlooked in the wrong choices.
Common Pitfalls:
- Using diode-rectifier (α = 0 only) values and generalizing incorrectly.
- Confusing Vm and Vrms when forming averages.
Final Answer:
Vdc1 = 0.5 Vdc2 for all firing angles