In hydrology, the peak discharge by the rational method is often expressed in terms of rainfall intensity, runoff coefficient, and catchment area. If rainfall intensity I is given in cm/hour, the runoff percentage is P (i.e., C = P/100), and the drainage area A is in km², what is the correct expression for total runoff discharge Q in m³/s?
-
AQ = 0.0278 * P * I * A
-
BQ = 0.278 * P * I * A
-
CQ = 2.78 * P * I * A
-
DQ = 27.8 * P * I * A
-
EQ = 0.00278 * P * I * A
Answer
Correct Answer: Q = 0.0278 * P * I * A
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Design runoff for small urban catchments is commonly estimated by the rational method. The discharge Q depends on rainfall intensity I, runoff coefficient C, and area A. Correct unit handling is crucial because I may be provided in cm/hour or mm/hour, and A may be provided in km². This problem tests your ability to convert units and write the proper discharge formula in m³/s.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- I is rainfall intensity in cm/hour.
- P is percentage runoff, so C = P/100 (dimensionless).
- A is the catchment area in km².
- We seek Q in m³/s.
Concept / Approach:The rational formula for discharge is Q = 0.278 * C * I_mm_per_hr * A_km2 when intensity is in mm/hour. If intensity is instead in cm/hour, we convert cm to mm or directly adjust the coefficient. Since 1 cm = 10 mm, I_mm_per_hr = 10 * I_cm_per_hr.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Start with Q = 0.278 * C * I_mm_per_hr * AReplace C by P/100 and I_mm_per_hr by (10 * I_cm_per_hr)Q = 0.278 * (P/100) * (10 * I) * AQ = 0.278 * 0.1 * P * I * AQ = 0.0278 * P * I * AVerification / Alternative check:A quick dimensional check: 0.278 works for mm/hour. Since 1 cm/hour equals 10 mm/hour, the coefficient must be divided by 10 to keep units consistent. Hence 0.0278 is correct for cm/hour.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Q = 0.278 * P * I * A: This wrongly treats I (cm/hour) as mm/hour.
- Q = 2.78 * P * I * A: Off by a factor of 100; unit conversion error.
- Q = 27.8 * P * I * A: Off by a factor of 1000; severe unit error.
- Q = 0.00278 * P * I * A: Off by a factor of 10 in the opposite direction.
Common Pitfalls:Mixing cm/hour and mm/hour in the rational formula; forgetting that A must be in km² for the 0.278 family of coefficients; using P directly as C without dividing by 100.
Final Answer:Q = 0.0278 * P * I * A