More Questions from Water Supply Engineering

In hydrology, the peak discharge by the rational method is often expressed in terms of rainfall intensity, runoff coefficient, and catchment area. If rainfall intensity I is given in cm/hour, the runoff percentage is P (i.e., C = P/100), and the drainage area A is in km², what is the correct expression for total runoff discharge Q in m³/s?

Civil Engineering Water Supply Engineering Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    Q = 0.0278 * P * I * A
  • B
    Q = 0.278 * P * I * A
  • C
    Q = 2.78 * P * I * A
  • D
    Q = 27.8 * P * I * A
  • E
    Q = 0.00278 * P * I * A

Answer

Correct Answer: Q = 0.0278 * P * I * A

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Design runoff for small urban catchments is commonly estimated by the rational method. The discharge Q depends on rainfall intensity I, runoff coefficient C, and area A. Correct unit handling is crucial because I may be provided in cm/hour or mm/hour, and A may be provided in km². This problem tests your ability to convert units and write the proper discharge formula in m³/s.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • I is rainfall intensity in cm/hour.
  • P is percentage runoff, so C = P/100 (dimensionless).
  • A is the catchment area in km².
  • We seek Q in m³/s.

Concept / Approach:The rational formula for discharge is Q = 0.278 * C * I_mm_per_hr * A_km2 when intensity is in mm/hour. If intensity is instead in cm/hour, we convert cm to mm or directly adjust the coefficient. Since 1 cm = 10 mm, I_mm_per_hr = 10 * I_cm_per_hr.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Start with Q = 0.278 * C * I_mm_per_hr * AReplace C by P/100 and I_mm_per_hr by (10 * I_cm_per_hr)Q = 0.278 * (P/100) * (10 * I) * AQ = 0.278 * 0.1 * P * I * AQ = 0.0278 * P * I * A

Verification / Alternative check:A quick dimensional check: 0.278 works for mm/hour. Since 1 cm/hour equals 10 mm/hour, the coefficient must be divided by 10 to keep units consistent. Hence 0.0278 is correct for cm/hour.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Q = 0.278 * P * I * A: This wrongly treats I (cm/hour) as mm/hour.
  • Q = 2.78 * P * I * A: Off by a factor of 100; unit conversion error.
  • Q = 27.8 * P * I * A: Off by a factor of 1000; severe unit error.
  • Q = 0.00278 * P * I * A: Off by a factor of 10 in the opposite direction.

Common Pitfalls:Mixing cm/hour and mm/hour in the rational formula; forgetting that A must be in km² for the 0.278 family of coefficients; using P directly as C without dividing by 100.

Final Answer:Q = 0.0278 * P * I * A

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion