Kinematics sign convention – gravity during upward throw When a body is thrown upward, should gravitational acceleration be taken as zero, positive g, or negative g in the vertical equation of motion?
-
ACorrect – take g = 0 while the body is going up
-
BIncorrect – use g with downward sign (−g if upward is positive)
-
CCorrect only near the top of the path
-
DCorrect in vacuum but not in air
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect – use g with downward sign (−g if upward is positive)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Projectile and vertical throw problems hinge on consistent sign conventions. Gravity does not switch off during ascent; it constantly accelerates the body downward. The statement claims g is taken as zero on upward motion—this must be evaluated.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Vertical 1-D motion under uniform gravity g.
- Choose upward as the positive axis (common convention).
- Neglect air resistance for clarity.
Concept / Approach:With upward positive, gravitational acceleration is a constant negative value: a = −g. Kinematic equations such as v = u + a t and s = u t + (1/2) a t^2 hold at all times, including ascent, apex, and descent. Setting g = 0 would eliminate the deceleration responsible for the body slowing down and turning.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Take upward positive; weight acts downward ⇒ a = −g.Use v = u + a t ⇒ at apex v = 0 occurs because a = −g reduces v from u to 0.Displacement: s = u t + (1/2)(−g) t^2 correctly gives a concave-down trajectory in time.Therefore, gravitational acceleration is not zero during ascent; it is constant and downward.Verification / Alternative check:Energy method: kinetic energy decreases on the way up because gravitational potential energy increases by m g h. If g were zero, there would be no energy exchange to halt the upward motion—contradicting observation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Correct near the top / in vacuum: gravity acts everywhere near Earth; vacuum removes drag only.
- g = 0 while going up: physically incorrect; gravity does not switch off.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing sign convention with magnitude. You always include g; the sign depends on chosen positive direction.
Final Answer:Incorrect – use g with downward sign (−g if upward is positive)