Vertical Curve Design – Deviation Angle Between Two Ascending Grades Two ascending gradients, 1 in 50 and 1 in 30, meet at a summit. What is the deviation angle A (algebraic difference of grades) to be used in vertical curve computations? Provide the closest standard expression.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: A = 1.33% (equivalently, about 1 in 75)

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
In geometric design of highways, the deviation angle A between two grades governs the required length of a vertical curve for comfort and sight distance. A is defined as the algebraic difference of grades, taking sign into account (ascending positive, descending negative). This question deals with computing A for two ascending grades meeting at a summit point.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Grade 1: +1 in 50.
  • Grade 2: +1 in 30.
  • Both are ascending (same sign).
  • Summit curve design context.


Concept / Approach:

Express each grade as a percentage: g = rise/run × 100. For 1 in N ascending, g = (1/N) × 100 %. The deviation angle A (for vertical curves) equals the absolute algebraic difference |g2 − g1| when both grades have the same sign. This A then enters formulas for curve length based on sight distance or comfort criteria.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Convert 1 in 50 to percent: g1 = (1/50) * 100 = 2.00%.Convert 1 in 30 to percent: g2 = (1/30) * 100 ≈ 3.333…%.Compute algebraic difference: A = |g2 − g1| = |3.333… − 2.00| ≈ 1.333…%.Express in a convenient equivalent: A ≈ 1.33%, which corresponds roughly to 1 in 75 (since 1/75 ≈ 0.0133).


Verification / Alternative check:

If one grade were descending, A would be the sum of absolute values. Here, since both are ascending, only the difference is taken, giving a relatively small A and therefore a shorter summit curve than if grades opposed each other.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • 3.33% and 2.00%: These are the individual grades, not the deviation angle.
  • 5.33%: Sum of 3.33% and 2.00%, applicable only if grades had opposite signs (one up, one down).


Common Pitfalls:

Forgetting to convert to percentage; adding instead of subtracting when grades have the same sign; mixing up algebraic difference (A) with the actual curve gradient at any point.


Final Answer:

A = 1.33% (equivalently, about 1 in 75)

More Questions from GATE Exam Questions

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion