Interpreting a low speed–power product — what does “lower is better” mean? As a general rule, a logic family with a lower speed–power product is preferable because it offers which combination of characteristics?
-
Along propagation delay and high power consumption
-
Blong propagation delay and low power consumption
-
Cshort propagation delay and high power consumption
-
Dshort propagation delay and low power consumption
-
Eneither speed nor power advantages
Answer
Correct Answer: short propagation delay and low power consumption
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The speed–power product (SPP) combines two core parameters into one metric. It is especially useful for comparing families across technology nodes or architectural styles. Understanding what a “low” value signifies helps engineers pick gates that deliver both performance and efficiency.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- SPP = propagation delay (ns) * power dissipation (mW).
- Lower SPP is better, all else equal.
- Comparisons should be made at similar voltage and temperature conditions.
Concept / Approach:Since the two terms multiply, a small product occurs when both factors are small. A logic family with very short delays but very high power may have a larger SPP than a moderately fast, low-power family. Conversely, a slow but ultra-low-power family can also end up with a larger SPP. The best families combine low delay and low power to minimize the product.
Step-by-Step Reasoning:
Let tp be small and PD be small → SPP is minimized.If either tp or PD is large, the product increases.Therefore, “lower is better” implies both fast (short tp) and efficient (low PD).Verification / Alternative check:Example: Family A, tp = 5 ns, PD = 20 mW ⇒ SPP = 100. Family B, tp = 10 ns, PD = 5 mW ⇒ SPP = 50. Family B is slower but much lower power, yielding a lower SPP and greater energy efficiency per operation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Long delays (options a, b) cannot yield small SPP regardless of power.
- “Short delay and high power” (option c) may still produce a large product.
- “No advantages” contradicts the definition of SPP.
Common Pitfalls:
- Comparing values without noting test frequency; average power can vary with toggle rate.
Final Answer:short propagation delay and low power consumption