Plane surveying on a spherical Earth: arc–chord difference over 18.2 km For a ground distance of 18.2 km measured along the Earth’s surface, what is the approximate difference between the arc length and its subtended chord length (take Earth radius ≈ 6,370 km)?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: 1 cm

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
On large-scale surveys, the difference between an arc along the Earth and the corresponding straight chord can matter in precision calculations. For moderate distances, a convenient approximation estimates this small difference accurately enough for engineering purposes. This question checks your ability to apply the standard small-angle formula for arc–chord difference.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Arc length s = 18.2 km = 18,200 m.
  • Mean Earth radius R ≈ 6,370 km = 6,370,000 m.
  • Small-angle approximation is valid for s ≪ 2πR.


Concept / Approach:

For small central angle, the difference (s − c) between arc length s and chord length c is approximated by s^3 / (24 * R^2). This follows from c = 2R * sin(s/(2R)) and the series sin x ≈ x − x^3/6 for small x. Substituting x = s/(2R) and simplifying yields the compact cubic expression in s with R constant.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Compute s^3: 18,200^3 ≈ 6.03 × 10^12 m^3.Compute R^2: (6.37 × 10^6)^2 ≈ 4.06 × 10^13 m^2.Use formula: s − c ≈ s^3 / (24 R^2).Numerically: (6.03 × 10^12) / (24 × 4.06 × 10^13) ≈ 6.2 × 10^−3 m ≈ 0.62 cm.Round to the nearest option → about 1 cm.


Verification / Alternative check:

A direct evaluation using c = 2R * sin(s/(2R)) with calculator precision gives the same order of magnitude (a few millimetres). For typical engineering mapping, rounding to 1 cm is fully justified.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

5 cm, 10 cm, and 100 cm greatly overestimate the arc–chord difference for only 18.2 km; such differences occur over far longer spans.


Common Pitfalls:

Confusing sagitta with arc–chord difference; misusing units (km vs m); neglecting the 24 in the denominator which comes from series expansion.


Final Answer:

1 cm

More Questions from Surveying

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion