In ER modeling, which type of entity cannot exist unless another entity exists, yet does not need to include the other entity's identifier as part of its own identifier?

Database Data Modeling with ER Model Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    Weak entity
  • B
    Strong entity
  • C
    ID-dependent entity
  • D
    ID- independent entity
  • E
    Associative entity

Answer

Correct Answer: ID- independent entity

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Some child entities require a parent for existence (mandatory relationship) but still have their own identifying key. Understanding the difference between ID-dependent and ID-independent situations determines how you choose primary keys and relationship types in the schema.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The child cannot exist unless the parent exists (existence-dependent).
  • The child's identifier does not include the parent's identifier.
  • We seek the term that describes this situation.

Concept / Approach:An ID-dependent entity uses a primary key that includes its parent's key (identifying relationship). By contrast, an ID-independent entity has its own primary key while still being existence-dependent on the parent (non-identifying relationship with mandatory participation). The prompt explicitly says the child does not require the parent's identifier in its own key, so the child is ID-independent.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Check dependence: child requires parent → existence-dependent.Check identifier composition: parent's ID is not part of child's ID → not ID-dependent.Therefore, the correct term is ID-independent entity with a mandatory relationship.

Verification / Alternative check:In Crow’s Foot modeling, this is modeled as a non-identifying relationship (dashed line) with required participation on the child side.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Weak entity: Typically implies identifying relationship using the parent’s key (ID-dependent). Strong entity: Has existence independent of any parent. ID-dependent entity: Contradicts the prompt because it must include the parent’s identifier. Associative entity: Resolves many-to-many relationships; not necessarily tied to this key behavior.

Common Pitfalls:Assuming all existence-dependent entities must be ID-dependent. Existence dependence and identification are related but distinct design choices.

Final Answer:ID- independent entity

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion