Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Tanuja
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This logical reasoning puzzle is based on classification and deduction from multiple overlapping sets. We have six women and information about who is a dancer, vocal musician, violinist, and actress. The task is to combine all the given constraints and identify which person must certainly be both a dancer and a violinist. Such questions train the ability to track conditions and use elimination to reach a unique conclusion.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
The key idea is to combine set membership information. We know how many people belong to each skill group overall, and we also know specific inclusions and exclusions. We must first identify all violinists, then intersect that set with the set of dancers. Any person who is certainly in both sets, regardless of other possibilities, is the required answer. Consistency with the total counts is also important, so we use the totals to confirm that no alternative assignment is possible.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: From the statement, Girija (G) and Vanaja (V) are violinists. So we already have two violinists: G and V.Step 2: Jalaja (J) and Shailaja (S) do not know how to play the violin, so they cannot be violinists.Step 3: The four vocal musicians are J, V, S, and Tanuja (T). Exactly two of these four are violinists.Step 4: Among these four vocal musicians, V is already known to be a violinist. Therefore, exactly one more among J, S, and T must be a violinist.Step 5: However, J and S are explicitly stated not to play the violin. Hence they cannot be the second violinist among this group.Step 6: Therefore, Tanuja must be the second violinist among the vocal musicians. So the three violinists overall are Girija, Vanaja, and Tanuja.Step 7: Shailaja and Tanuja are dancers. Therefore, Tanuja is both a dancer and a violinist. Shailaja is a dancer but not a violinist. Girija and Vanaja are violinists but are not forced by the statements to be dancers.Step 8: Hence the only woman who is certainly both a dancer and a violinist is Tanuja.
Verification / Alternative check:
Check the total counts. There are three violinists: G, V, and T. This matches the requirement of three violinists. Vocal musicians are J, V, S, and T, and among them, exactly two (V and T) are violinists, which also matches the given condition. There are four dancers, and we already know S and T are dancers, while the remaining two dancers can be selected from G, V, J, and P without affecting the conclusion about who must be both dancer and violinist. Every condition can be satisfied with Tanuja as a dancer and violinist, and no other person is forced into that combination by the data.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Common Pitfalls:
Final Answer:
The woman who is both a dancer and a violinist is Tanuja.
Discussion & Comments