Power consumption comparison — CMOS vs. TTL: Evaluate the statement: “CMOS logic circuits generally consume less power than TTL circuits.” Consider quiescent conditions and typical operating regimes.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Correct

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Choosing a logic family often starts with power, speed, and noise margin. Complementary MOS (CMOS) logic became dominant in modern electronics largely because of its very low static power, in contrast to TTL’s continuous bias currents. This question probes the broad, widely taught comparison between these families.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • We compare classic 5 V TTL families with standard CMOS families at comparable supply voltages.
  • Quiescent (static) power is emphasized; dynamic power in CMOS depends on switching activity.
  • Ambient and loading are typical; extreme edge cases are not the focus.


Concept / Approach:
CMOS uses complementary pull-up/pull-down transistors with negligible DC current when inputs are at valid logic levels and outputs are not transitioning. Hence static power is near zero, rising mainly with switching due to charging/discharging capacitances (P_dynamic ≈ C_load * V^2 * f). TTL, based on bipolar transistors, draws significant DC bias current even when idle. Therefore, on average, CMOS consumes far less power, especially at low to moderate frequencies and light loads.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify CMOS static behavior: near-zero DC current in steady states.Identify TTL static behavior: continuous currents through bias networks.Compare typical figures: CMOS microamps vs. TTL milliamps per gate at 5 V.Conclude the statement is correct in general practice.


Verification / Alternative check:
Datasheets exhibit quiescent current I_CC on the order of microamps for 74HC/74HCT gates versus milliamps for 74LS/74ALS gates, confirming the power advantage of CMOS at rest and typical switching rates.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Incorrect: Contradicts family fundamentals.
  • Only above 10 MHz / only at 5 V / depends only on fan-out: While voltage, frequency, and load affect power, the static-current contrast remains the dominant factor.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming CMOS always wins at any frequency and voltage; at extremely high speeds or very low voltages the comparison can be nuanced, but the general statement remains true for mainstream use.


Final Answer:
Correct

More Questions from Standard Logic Devices (SLD)

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion