Laminar flow criterion in open channels For open-channel flow, the motion is considered laminar when the Reynolds number (based on hydraulic radius) is below what threshold?
-
Aless than 500
-
Bmore than 500
-
Cexactly 1000
-
Dnone of these
-
Eless than 200
Answer
Correct Answer: less than 500
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Classifying open-channel flow as laminar or turbulent guides the choice of resistance equations and roughness parameters. While pipes commonly use a 2300 threshold, open channels use a different criterion due to the free surface and characteristic length choice (hydraulic radius).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Reynolds number for channels: Re = V R_h / ν, where R_h = A/P.
- Newtonian fluid (water), steady uniform flow conceptually.
- Free surface effects present.
Concept / Approach:
Empirical evidence places laminar-channel behavior at Re below approximately 500. For 500 < Re < 2000, transitional effects may occur, and above roughly 2000, fully turbulent regimes dominate for most practical channels.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Compute Re = V R_h / ν.If Re < 500 → laminar; Re ≫ 500 → turbulent/transition.Select appropriate resistance relation (e.g., Hagen–Poiseuille analog only for laminar).Verification / Alternative check:
Compare observed velocity profiles: laminar exhibits parabolic profile; turbulent shows fuller profile and eddy viscosity behavior.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
(b) and (c) do not represent the typical laminar threshold in channels. (d) is incorrect as a practical criterion exists. (e) is overly conservative for channels.
Common Pitfalls:
Using the pipe threshold (2300) directly for open channels; choosing wrong characteristic length (use hydraulic radius, not depth alone).
Final Answer:
less than 500