Sensitivity of rectangular-notch discharge to head-measurement error For a rectangular weir/notch where Q ∝ H^(3/2), the ratio of percentage error in discharge to percentage error in head measurement is
-
A1/2
-
B2/3
-
C3/2
-
D3/4
-
E2
Answer
Correct Answer: 3/2
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Discharge over a rectangular notch is commonly expressed as Q = C_d b √(2 g) H^(3/2). Because Q depends on H to the 3/2 power, small errors in head gauging can translate into larger fractional errors in discharge. Quantifying this sensitivity is essential in flow measurement practice.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Rectangular notch, free nappe conditions.
- Discharge varies as H^(3/2), other factors held constant.
- Small measurement errors (use differentials/relative errors).
Concept / Approach:
If Q ∝ H^n, then dQ/Q = n (dH/H). Here n = 3/2. Thus the ratio of fractional (percentage) errors is 3/2.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Q = K H^(3/2) for constant K.Take logarithmic differential: dQ/Q = (3/2) dH/H.Therefore %ΔQ / %ΔH = 3/2.Verification / Alternative check:
A 1% head error yields approximately a 1.5% discharge error, matching field experience that accurate head measurement is critical.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
(a), (b), and (d) understate the sensitivity; (e) overstates it for a rectangular notch.
Common Pitfalls:
Confusing rectangular notch (exponent 3/2) with triangular notch where exponent differs (5/2), changing sensitivity.
Final Answer:
3/2