Slope stability using Taylor’s charts: A 40° slope is excavated to a depth of 10 m in saturated clay (γ = 20 kN/m^3, cu = 70 kN/m^2, φu = 0). Given Taylor’s stability coefficient S = 0.18 for φu = 0 at θ = 40°, estimate the factor of safety.
-
A2.0
-
B2.1
-
C2.2
-
D2.3
-
E1.8
Answer
Correct Answer: 2.0
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Taylor’s stability charts provide a rapid estimate of slope safety in purely cohesive (φu = 0) soils by linking soil strength, slope geometry, and unit weight through the stability number. When the stability coefficient S for a given slope angle is known, the factor of safety (F) can be obtained without a full slip-circle search.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Slope angle θ = 40°, depth H = 10 m.
- Saturated undrained clay: cu = 70 kN/m^2, φu = 0, γ = 20 kN/m^3.
- Taylor coefficient S = 0.18 for φu = 0, θ = 40°.
Concept / Approach:
For φu = 0, the stability number is defined as S = cu / (γ H) at F = 1. For a general factor of safety F, the relationship extends to cu / (γ H) = S * F. Therefore, F = (cu / (γ H)) / S.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Compute cu / (γ H) = 70 / (20 * 10) = 70 / 200 = 0.35.Use S = 0.18 → F = 0.35 / 0.18 ≈ 1.94.Round to the nearest listed value → F ≈ 2.0.Verification / Alternative check:
Comparing with detailed charts or a slip surface analysis yields a factor of safety close to 2 for the chosen parameters, validating the estimate.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 2.1–2.3: Slightly higher than the computed 1.94; 2.0 is the nearest correct option.
- 1.8: Too low relative to the computed ratio.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing S definitions; ensure S corresponds to φu = 0 charts.
- Using total stress friction angle instead of undrained parameters.
Final Answer:
2.0