Supports for vertical process vessels: Which of the following is NOT used for vertical vessels?
-
ABrackets (wall or structural brackets).
-
BSkirts.
-
CColumns/legs.
-
DSaddles.
Answer
Correct Answer: Saddles.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Support selection depends on vessel orientation, size, and thermal expansion needs. Correct supports are critical for mechanical integrity and nozzle alignment.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Vessels are cylindrical.
- Vertical vessels are mounted upright on foundations or structures.
Concept / Approach:Vertical vessels are commonly supported by skirts (for tall/heavy towers), columns or legs (for smaller vessels), or brackets (for wall/structure mounting). Saddles, by contrast, cradle a horizontal cylinder and are inappropriate for vertical orientation.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify typical vertical supports: skirts, legs/columns, brackets.Recognize saddles: designed for horizontal vessels with two cradles supporting shell curvature.Therefore, saddles are not used for vertical vessels.Verification / Alternative check:Mechanical design handbooks depict standard support details; vertical vessels rarely, if ever, use saddles.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Brackets, skirts, and columns are well-established supports for vertical vessels.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming one support fits all orientations; each has distinct load paths and thermal considerations (e.g., skirts accommodate nozzle loads and differential expansion).
Final Answer:Saddles.