More Questions from Mechanical Operations

Among the following minerals, which one has the minimum Rittinger’s number (i.e., requires the least energy per unit new surface area created) under comparable conditions?

Chemical Engineering Mechanical Operations Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    Calcite
  • B
    Pyrite
  • C
    Quartz
  • D
    Galena
  • E
    Feldspar

Answer

Correct Answer: Galena

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Rittinger’s number reflects the energy needed to create unit new surface. Softer, cleavage-prone minerals typically show lower values than hard, tough minerals.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Minerals listed: calcite, pyrite, quartz, galena.
  • Measurements compared at similar size ranges and conditions.

Concept / Approach:Quartz is very hard and tough, implying a high Rittinger’s number. Pyrite and calcite are moderate; galena (lead sulfide) is very soft and exhibits perfect cleavage, making surface generation easier and energy per area lower, hence a smaller Rittinger’s number.

Step-by-Step Solution:Rank by hardness/toughness: quartz > pyrite ≈ calcite > galena.Associate lower hardness/cleavage with lower energy per area.Select galena as minimum.

Verification / Alternative check:Grinding practice shows galena liberates readily with less power compared with quartz-bearing ores.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Quartz: very high energy per surface created.Pyrite/Calcite: higher than galena though lower than quartz.

Common Pitfalls:Equating Mohs hardness linearly with grindability; cleavage also matters.

Final Answer:Galena

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion