Among the following minerals, which one has the minimum Rittinger’s number (i.e., requires the least energy per unit new surface area created) under comparable conditions?
-
ACalcite
-
BPyrite
-
CQuartz
-
DGalena
-
EFeldspar
Answer
Correct Answer: Galena
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Rittinger’s number reflects the energy needed to create unit new surface. Softer, cleavage-prone minerals typically show lower values than hard, tough minerals.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Minerals listed: calcite, pyrite, quartz, galena.
- Measurements compared at similar size ranges and conditions.
Concept / Approach:Quartz is very hard and tough, implying a high Rittinger’s number. Pyrite and calcite are moderate; galena (lead sulfide) is very soft and exhibits perfect cleavage, making surface generation easier and energy per area lower, hence a smaller Rittinger’s number.
Step-by-Step Solution:Rank by hardness/toughness: quartz > pyrite ≈ calcite > galena.Associate lower hardness/cleavage with lower energy per area.Select galena as minimum.
Verification / Alternative check:Grinding practice shows galena liberates readily with less power compared with quartz-bearing ores.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Quartz: very high energy per surface created.Pyrite/Calcite: higher than galena though lower than quartz.
Common Pitfalls:Equating Mohs hardness linearly with grindability; cleavage also matters.
Final Answer:Galena