Particle settling by Stokes’ law: If a 10 μm sphere settles with velocity v in a Newtonian oil (SG 0.9, μ = 10 poise), what is the settling velocity of a 20 μm sphere in the same oil (all else equal)?
-
ASame as the 10 μm particle
-
BOne fourth of the 10 μm particle
-
CTwice that of the 10 μm particle
-
DFour times that of the 10 μm particle
-
EEight times that of the 10 μm particle
Answer
Correct Answer: Four times that of the 10 μm particle
Explanation
Introduction / Context:In the creeping-flow regime (Reynolds number much less than 1), Stokes’ law gives the terminal settling velocity of small spheres in a viscous fluid. Understanding how velocity scales with particle diameter is essential in sedimentation and centrifugation design.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Spherical particles with diameters d1 = 10 μm and d2 = 20 μm.
- Same oil, so identical density and viscosity.
- Stokes regime applies (laminar drag, Re << 1).
Concept / Approach:Under Stokes’ law, terminal velocity v_t is proportional to d^2 for a given density difference and viscosity. Thus, doubling the diameter multiplies v_t by 2^2 = 4.
Step-by-Step Solution:Let v1 ∝ d1^2 and v2 ∝ d2^2.Given d2 = 2 * d1, then v2 / v1 = (d2/d1)^2 = 2^2 = 4.Therefore, v2 = 4 * v1.
Verification / Alternative check:Dimensionally and from the Stokes expression v_t = (g * (ρ_p - ρ_f) * d^2) / (18 * μ), the quadratic dependence on diameter is explicit, confirming the 4x scaling.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Same or one fourth: contradict the d^2 proportionality.
- Twice: would correspond to linear scaling, not Stokes regime.
- Eight times: would imply cubic scaling, incorrect for Stokes settling.
Common Pitfalls:Applying turbulent or intermediate drag correlations instead of Stokes law; forgetting that shape and agglomeration can alter effective drag.
Final Answer:Four times that of the 10 μm particle