Construction insight: Can a D flip-flop be formed by simply inserting an inverter between the SET input and the clock terminal? Evaluate this claim relative to standard D flip-flop implementations from latches or J–K equivalents.
-
AIncorrect
-
BCorrect
-
CTrue only with master–slave SR core
-
DDepends on asynchronous clear only
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect
Explanation
Introduction / Context: Understanding how different flip-flops relate helps when converting between primitives or when a required type is unavailable. A D flip-flop can be constructed from lower-level elements, but the relationships must preserve synchronous behavior and proper control of set/reset paths.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- SET and CLEAR are asynchronous override inputs on many flip-flops.
- The clock input governs synchronous sampling of the data path.
- The claim suggests adding an inverter between SET and CLOCK to create a D flip-flop.
Concept / Approach: A valid construction routes combinational logic so that the synchronous data path implements Q(next) = D at the active clock edge. Typical conversions include: building a D flip-flop from a pair of level-sensitive D latches (master–slave) or from a J–K by wiring J = D and K = D’ (complement). Inserting an inverter between SET and CLOCK does not create a proper synchronous data path; it misuses an asynchronous control and risks forcing states independent of clocking, violating setup/hold timing and the intended function.
Step-by-Step Solution:
State valid method: D FF = master latch + slave latch with opposite level enables.Alternative: From J–K, wire J = D and K = D’ to realize D behavior on the clock edge.Evaluate the claim: SET is asynchronous; inverting it into CLOCK path does not synthesize D behavior.Conclude: the statement is incorrect.Verification / Alternative check:
Simulate timing: any change on SET immediately overrides Q, independent of clock edge; this is not a D flip-flop.Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Correct / True only with SR core / Depends on clear: None repair the fundamental misuse of asynchronous controls.Common Pitfalls:
Confusing asynchronous preset/clear with synchronous data inputs.Ignoring the two-latch (master–slave) structure that enforces edge behavior.Final Answer:
Incorrect