Shear force sign change and bending moment: At a section where the shear force changes sign, what happens to the bending moment?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: It attains an extremum (maximum or minimum) at that section

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Shear force (V) and bending moment (M) are related by beam theory: dM/dx = V and dV/dx = w, where w is the load intensity. Recognizing the qualitative link between the sign of V and extrema of M is key in plotting diagrams quickly and accurately.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Prismatic beam with standard loading.
  • Shear force diagram (SFD) crosses the zero line (sign change) at a particular section.
  • Continuum mechanics relations apply (beam is linearly elastic within the analysis region).


Concept / Approach:
If dM/dx = V, then where V = 0, the slope of the bending moment diagram is zero, which indicates a local extremum (maximum or minimum) in M, provided the function is smooth there. Hence a sign change in V broadly marks a peak or valley in M, not necessarily a zero moment value.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Use dM/dx = V.At the section of interest, V = 0 (sign change implies crossing through zero).Therefore, dM/dx = 0 → M has an extremum at that section.


Verification / Alternative check:
Plot M for a simply supported beam with UDL: V crosses zero at midspan and M is maximum there. For a cantilever with point load at the tip, V does not change sign in span and M is monotonic—consistent with the rule.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Zero moment occurs at supports of simply supported beams, not necessarily where V changes sign. Infinity/undefined is non-physical here. Constancy of M implies V = 0 everywhere in that region, which is not the case around a sign change.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming “zero shear implies zero moment.” The correct inference is an extremum of M, not necessarily M = 0.


Final Answer:
It attains an extremum (maximum or minimum) at that section

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion