Statement: You should not drink. You must take care of your health, says Ramesh to his friend Ravi. Assumptions: I. Ravi will heed Ramesh’s advice. II. Ramesh knows the ill effects of drinking. III. Drinking is not good for health. Choose the option that identifies the implicit assumption or assumptions.
-
AII and III are implicit
-
BNone is implicit
-
CAll are implicit
-
DI and III are implicit
-
EOnly II is implicit
Answer
Correct Answer: II and III are implicit
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Advice statements typically presume a reason and a belief about consequences. We identify which premises the advisor relies on when urging a friend to avoid drinking for health.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Ramesh links drinking behavior to health outcomes.
- The recommendation is framed as health-protective.
- Whether Ravi will comply is unknown.
Concept / Approach:An assumption is implicit if the advice would lose sense without it.
Step-by-Step Solution:I: Not implicit. Advice can be offered even if the advisor doubts compliance.II: Implicit. The speaker must believe drinking has ill effects to offer health-based advice.III: Implicit. The advice presumes that drinking harms health, hence avoiding it protects health.
Verification / Alternative check:Health-based recommendations typically rest on causal beliefs about harm.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Including I adds an unnecessary compliance belief; single II omits the general health premise in III; “None” contradicts the clear health assumptions.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing intention to comply with the rationale for advice.
Final Answer:II and III are implicit