Negative feedback stability: For an amplifier with loop gain Aβ, which value of |Aβ| among the given choices yields the most stable closed-loop operation (largest stability margins)?
-
A0.95
-
B0.70
-
C1.20
-
D1.50
-
EExactly 1.00
Answer
Correct Answer: 0.70
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Stability of feedback amplifiers depends on the loop gain magnitude |Aβ| and loop phase. As the Nyquist/Bode criteria indicate, getting too close to the critical point (|Aβ| = 1 with −180° phase) risks oscillation. This question checks conceptual understanding of how loop-gain magnitude influences robustness.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Negative feedback is used.
- We compare only the magnitudes |Aβ| at the frequency where phase lag approaches −180°.
- Other factors (phase margin, pole locations) are comparable.
Concept / Approach:
Greater stability margin occurs when the locus stays farther from the critical point. Therefore, for similar phase conditions, a smaller |Aβ| provides larger gain margin and usually better phase margin.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify the smallest |Aβ| among options: 0.70.At |Aβ| = 0.70, the distance from the critical value 1 is largest, improving gain margin.Options with |Aβ| > 1 (1.20, 1.50) are potentially unstable if the phase lag nears −180°.Verification / Alternative check:
Bode plot reasoning: with the unity-gain crossover well below the −180° phase point, phase margin is increased; reducing |Aβ| helps achieve that condition.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 0.95: closer to unity → smaller margins.
- 1.20 and 1.50: loop magnitude > 1 at critical phase → risk of oscillation.
- Exactly 1.00: marginal stability.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming larger |Aβ| always improves performance; it improves accuracy but can harm stability if phase margin is limited.
Final Answer:
0.70.