A can build up a wall in 8 days while B can break it in 3 days. A has worked for 4 days and then B joined to work with A for another 2 days only. In how many days will A alone build up the remaining part of the wall?
Aptitude
Time and Work
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A$6\frac{1}{3}$ days
-
B7 days
-
C$7\frac{1}{3}$ days
-
D$13\frac{1}{3}$ days
Answer
Correct Answer: $7\frac{1}{3}$ days
Explanation
### Concept & Negative Work
When an entity destroys or reverses the work being done, their work rate is considered negative.
$$ \text{Net Work} = \text{Positive Work Rate} - \text{Negative Work Rate} $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Given:** A can build in 8 days, B can break in 3 days.
* A's 1 day work = $1/8$
* B's 1 day work = $-1/3$ (negative because B is destroying the wall)
* A works alone for 4 days: Work done = $4 \times (1/8) = 1/2$.
* A and B work together for 2 days: Work done = $2 \times (1/8 - 1/3) = 2 \times (\frac{3 - 8}{24}) = 2 \times (-5/24) = -5/12$.
* Net work completed so far = $1/2 - 5/12 = 6/12 - 5/12 = 1/12$.
* Remaining work to be done = $1 - 1/12 = 11/12$.
* Now, A alone must complete this $11/12$ of the wall.
* Time taken by A alone = $\frac{\text{Remaining Work}}{\text{A's Rate}} = \frac{11/12}{1/8} = \frac{11}{12} \times 8 = 22/3 = 7\frac{1}{3}$ days.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Use the LCM method. LCM of 8 and 3 is 24. Let total work = 24 units.
A's efficiency = $+3$ units/day. B's efficiency = $-8$ units/day.
A works for 4 days: $4 \times 3 = 12$ units.
A and B work for 2 days: $2 \times (3 - 8) = 2 \times (-5) = -10$ units.
Total work done = $12 - 10 = 2$ units.
Remaining work = $24 - 2 = 22$ units.
A finishes the remaining work alone: $22 / 3 = 7\frac{1}{3}$ days.
### Common Pitfall
Forgetting to assign a negative value to B's work rate, or miscalculating the net remaining work by adding B's destructive effort instead of subtracting it.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **$7\frac{1}{3}$ days**.