A and B start a business with investments of ₹ 5000 and ₹ 4500 respectively. After 4 months, A takes out half of his capital. After two more months, B takes out one-third of his capital while C joins them with a capital of ₹ 7000. At the end of a year, they earn a profit of ₹ 5080. Find the share of each member in the profit. (Bank P.O., 2003)
Aptitude
Partnership
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
AA - ₹ 1400, B - ₹ 1900, C - ₹ 1780
-
BA - ₹ 1600, B - ₹ 1800, C - ₹ 1680
-
CA - ₹ 1800, B - ₹ 1500, C - ₹ 1780
-
DA - ₹ 1680, B - ₹ 1600, C - ₹ 1800
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: A - ₹ 1600, B - ₹ 1800, C - ₹ 1680
Explanation
### Concept & Profit Ratio
Profits are shared in the ratio of the "capital-months" contributed by each partner over the course of the business period.
$$ \text{Equivalent Capital} = \sum (\text{Capital} \times \text{Time Period}) $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **A's Equivalent Capital:**
* ₹ 5000 for 4 months.
* Withdraws half (₹ 2500), leaving ₹ 2500 for the remaining 8 months.
* A's Capital = $(5000 \times 4) + (2500 \times 8) = 20000 + 20000 = 40000$
* **B's Equivalent Capital:**
* ₹ 4500 for 6 months (4 months + 2 more months).
* Withdraws one-third ($\frac{1}{3} \times 4500 = 1500$), leaving ₹ 3000 for the remaining 6 months.
* B's Capital = $(4500 \times 6) + (3000 \times 6) = 27000 + 18000 = 45000$
* **C's Equivalent Capital:**
* Joins after 6 months with ₹ 7000. The money is invested for the remaining 6 months.
* C's Capital = $7000 \times 6 = 42000$
* **Profit Ratio:**
* $A : B : C = 40000 : 45000 : 42000 = 40 : 45 : 42$
* **Total Profit:** ₹ 5080
* Total ratio units = $40 + 45 + 42 = 127$ units.
* Value of 1 unit = $\frac{5080}{127} = 40$
* **Individual Shares:**
* A's Share = $40 \times 40 = \text{₹ } 1600$
* B's Share = $45 \times 40 = \text{₹ } 1800$
* C's Share = $42 \times 40 = \text{₹ } 1680$
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Once you establish the ratio $40 : 45 : 42$, quickly check the options. The shares must be proportional to these numbers. Since A's ratio is 40 and B's is 45, B's share must be slightly larger than A's. Option (b) fits this perfectly ($1600 : 1800$).
### Common Pitfall
Misinterpreting "takes out one-third of his capital" as leaving one-third. B removes ₹ 1500, which means ₹ 3000 remains in the business.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **A - ₹ 1600, B - ₹ 1800, C - ₹ 1680**.