AC voltage control of a 3-phase induction motor using a 3-phase AC regulator For which load torque characteristic does stator-voltage control produce the largest speed variation?
-
ALoad torque is constant (independent of speed)
-
BLoad torque increases with speed
-
CLoad torque decreases with speed
-
DEither (a) or (b)
-
ELoad torque is zero
Answer
Correct Answer: Load torque is constant (independent of speed)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Three-phase AC regulators vary the RMS stator voltage of induction motors, thereby modifying breakdown and rated torque approximately with V^2. The resulting operating speed depends on the intersection of the motor torque–slip curve and the load torque characteristic.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Standard squirrel-cage induction motor.
- Stator voltage control (not frequency control).
- Torque capability scales roughly as V^2 for a given slip region.
Concept / Approach:When voltage is reduced, available motor torque drops quickly (∝ V^2). For a constant-torque load, maintaining the same torque requires substantially higher slip, which means a larger reduction in speed. For loads where torque rises with speed (e.g., positive viscous damping), the operating point tends to stabilize at a higher speed for a given voltage; for fan-type loads where torque decreases with speed, the required torque falls, so speed drop is smaller.
Step-by-Step Solution:Reduce voltage → motor torque curve scales down with V^2.Constant-torque demand → intersection shifts to much higher slip → larger speed reduction.For torque ∝ speed or torque ∝ speed^2, the required torque reduces at lower speed → less shift needed → smaller variation.
Verification / Alternative check:Plot approximate torque–slip curves under different voltages and superimpose constant versus speed-dependent load torques; the constant-torque case shows the greatest speed change.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- (b) and (c): speed-dependent torques moderate the drop in speed when voltage is reduced.
- (d): only (a) gives the largest variation.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming voltage control is an efficient speed control method for constant-torque loads—it is not.
Final Answer:Load torque is constant (independent of speed)