Willian's law (throttle-governed steam engine) — dependence of hourly steam consumption According to Willian's law, for a throttle-governed engine, the steam consumption per hour is proportional to which function of indicated power (I.P.)?

Mechanical Engineering Steam Boilers and Engines Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    sqrt(I.P.)
  • B
    a + b * (I.P.)^0
  • C
    I.P.
  • D
    (I.P.)^2
  • E
    1 / I.P.

Answer

Correct Answer: I.P.

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Willian's law is an empirical relationship used to assess steam rate and efficiency trends of throttle-governed steam engines. It allows linear extrapolation of steam consumption against indicated power to estimate no-load steam usage and frictional losses.Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Throttle (not cut-off) governing — steam pressure at the cylinder is throttled as load changes.
  • Hourly steam consumption m and indicated power I.P. are measured over several loads.
  • Linearity holds within the tested operating range.

Concept / Approach:The Willian's line is typically expressed as m = a + b * I.P. where a is the intercept representing no-load steam consumption (to overcome mechanical and pumping losses) and b is the slope representing steam rate per unit indicated power. Thus, m varies linearly with I.P., i.e., is proportional to I.P. once the constant offset a is recognized.Step-by-Step Solution:

Collect test points (I.P., m) at different loads under throttle governing.Fit a straight line: m = a + b * I.P.Infer functional dependence: dominant term varies directly with I.P., demonstrating proportionality.

Verification / Alternative check:Plotting m versus I.P. yields a straight line — the Willian's line. Extrapolation to I.P. = 0 gives intercept a (no-load steam), while slope b provides specific steam consumption per unit indicated power.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • sqrt(I.P.) or (I.P.)^2 or 1/I.P.: not supported by throttle-governed empirical data.
  • Constant-only forms ignore the clear load dependence captured by b * I.P.

Common Pitfalls:Applying Willian's law to cut-off governed engines (where relation is not linear); misinterpreting the intercept as zero; mixing indicated with brake power when plotting steam rate.

Final Answer:

I.P.
Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion