In network security, what is the Wide-Mouth Frog protocol?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: An authentication protocol in which a trusted server distributes fresh symmetric keys between parties based on messages from the initiating party

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Wide-Mouth Frog is the name of a simple authentication protocol discussed in cryptography and network security literature. It is one of several illustrative protocols, along with Needham–Schroeder and Kerberos, that show different ways of using symmetric keys and trusted servers to establish secure communication between parties. Understanding Wide-Mouth Frog helps students analyze protocol design choices, strengths and weaknesses.


Given Data / Assumptions:

    We are in the context of symmetric key authentication and key distribution protocols.
    A trusted server is available to help establish keys between communicating parties.
    The name Wide-Mouth Frog refers to a specific protocol design, not to congestion control or routing algorithms.
    The question asks for the nature of this protocol.


Concept / Approach:
In the Wide-Mouth Frog protocol, each user shares a long term symmetric key with a trusted authentication server. When one party (say A) wants to start a secure session with another party (say B), A constructs a message containing a newly generated session key and B's identity, encrypts it with A's long term key and sends it to the server. The server decrypts this, decides whether the request is acceptable and then forwards an encrypted message to B containing the session key and A's identity, encrypted under B's long term key. B can now decrypt the server's message and learn the session key to use with A. Freshness is usually provided by timestamps.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify the players: two users A and B, and a trusted server S. Each user shares a secret key with S. Step 2: A generates a fresh session key K and prepares a message containing K and B's identity, protected with the long term key between A and S. Step 3: S decrypts this message, checks the information and constructs a new message for B containing K and A's identity, encrypted with the long term key between B and S. Step 4: B receives S's message, decrypts it, and learns the session key K and the identity of A, allowing A and B to communicate securely using K. Step 5: Observe that this is clearly an authentication and key distribution protocol using a trusted server, not a congestion control, spam filtering or routing mechanism.


Verification / Alternative check:
Standard cryptography textbooks describe Wide-Mouth Frog as a symmetric key authentication and key distribution protocol and analyze its reliance on timestamps, trust in the server and vulnerability to compromised clocks. They do not associate the protocol with TCP congestion control, email classification or wireless routing, confirming the security authentication role given in option A.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
TCP congestion control algorithms include Slow Start, Congestion Avoidance and Fast Recovery, but none are called Wide-Mouth Frog.
Spam filtering techniques operate at the content and header level of email and are not usually given such names in protocol specifications.
Routing algorithms for wireless ad hoc networks focus on discovering and maintaining paths in a dynamic topology; they are unrelated to symmetric key authentication protocols.


Common Pitfalls:
Because Wide-Mouth Frog has a playful name, students sometimes misremember its purpose or confuse it with other whimsical names in computing. Another pitfall is to assume that any named mechanism in networking must relate to routing or congestion control. In security, many protocols have distinctive names, so it is important to recall whether the context was authentication, key distribution or something else.


Final Answer:
Wide-Mouth Frog is a symmetric key based authentication and key distribution protocol in which a trusted server distributes fresh session keys between parties, based on messages initiated by the requesting party.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion