In the context of Earth's internal processes, which geologist is widely credited with propounding the convectional current hypothesis to explain the movement of continents and the Earth's crust?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Arthur Holmes

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The structure of the Earth and the movement of its crust are central topics in physical geography and geology. Early theories such as continental drift and later plate tectonics required a mechanism to explain how massive plates could move over geological time. The convectional current hypothesis proposed that currents within the Earth's mantle help drive this movement. This question asks you to identify the geologist who is most closely associated with formulating this important hypothesis.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The focus is on the convectional current hypothesis in Earth's mantle.
  • We are asked who propounded this idea in a geographic and geologic context.
  • Options include Carl Ritter, Immanuel Kant, Arthur Holmes, and Arnaldo Faustini.
  • We assume knowledge of major contributors to theories of Earth's internal dynamics.


Concept / Approach:
Arthur Holmes was a British geologist who made significant contributions to understanding the age and internal structure of the Earth. In the early twentieth century, he proposed that convection currents in the mantle could provide the driving mechanism for continental drift. According to his hypothesis, heat from radioactive decay in the Earth's interior creates rising and sinking currents of semi molten rock, which in turn drag segments of the crust along. This idea laid groundwork for the modern theory of plate tectonics. Carl Ritter and Immanuel Kant were great thinkers but are known more for general geography and philosophy, not for proposing mantle convection as a mechanism for crustal movement. Arnaldo Faustini contributed to polar studies but is not associated with this hypothesis, leaving Arthur Holmes as the correct answer.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify that the question relates to internal Earth processes and continental movement. Step 2: Recall that Arthur Holmes proposed mantle convection currents as a mechanism to support Alfred Wegener's continental drift idea. Step 3: Note that his convectional current hypothesis suggested rising and falling mantle material that could move crustal plates. Step 4: Recognise that Carl Ritter was a pioneer in geography and Kant a philosopher, neither known for mantle convection theories. Step 5: Conclude that Arthur Holmes is the geologist credited with this hypothesis, making option C correct.


Verification / Alternative check:
Physical geography and geology textbooks consistently mention Arthur Holmes when describing early ideas about convection currents in the mantle. They often present a historical timeline where Wegener introduced continental drift, but Holmes provided a feasible driving mechanism through mantle convection. Later development of plate tectonics adopted and refined this concept. By contrast, reference works on Carl Ritter, Immanuel Kant, and Arnaldo Faustini do not associate them with convectional current hypotheses, confirming Holmes as the key figure.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Carl Ritter is considered one of the founders of modern geography, focusing on regional studies and the relationship between humans and environments, but he did not formulate mantle convection theories, so option A is incorrect. Immanuel Kant was a philosopher who contributed to ideas about space and time but not to the specific geophysical mechanism of convectional currents in the Earth, making option B wrong. Arnaldo Faustini was involved in polar exploration and cartography, not in theorising about mantle convection, so option D is also incorrect. Only Arthur Holmes is directly linked to the convectional current hypothesis used to explain crustal movements.


Common Pitfalls:
Students sometimes mix up names because many scientists and thinkers are mentioned in the historical development of Earth science. Another pitfall is to assume that any early geographic thinker such as Ritter or Kant must also have proposed internal Earth theories. To avoid this, remember the specific association: Wegener for continental drift, Holmes for mantle convection currents, and later scientists for plate tectonics. Keeping this sequence clear makes such questions easier to answer.


Final Answer:
The convectional current hypothesis explaining movement within the Earth's mantle was propounded by Arthur Holmes.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion