Vector stability in yeast — which is most genetically stable in vivo? Among common Saccharomyces cerevisiae vector systems, which type is generally the most stable because it integrates into the host genome?
Correct Answer: YIp (yeast integrative plasmid)
Introduction / Context:Different yeast vector classes balance copy number, stability, and ease of selection. Stability refers to faithful maintenance of genetic information over many cell divisions without selection pressure.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- YIp vectors integrate into the yeast genome via homologous recombination.
- YEp vectors replicate episomally using 2μm sequences and can be lost without selection.
- YRp vectors with ARS can be unstable due to poor segregation.
- YCp vectors behave like mini-chromosomes but can be lost at low frequency.
Concept / Approach:
Integration into the host genome provides maximal genetic stability because the inserted sequence segregates with chromosomes. Episomal or ARS-based plasmids can be diluted or mis-segregated over time, particularly without selective pressure. Therefore, YIp is typically the most stable choice for long-term maintenance.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Define stability as retention over many generations without selection.Recognize integrative vectors (YIp) recombine into chromosomal DNA.Contrast with episomal (YEp) and ARS-based (YRp) plasmids.Select YIp as most stable.Verification / Alternative check:
Yeast genetics manuals recommend YIp for gene replacement or stable integration, reflecting empirical stability compared with plasmid-based systems.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
YEp/YRp may be lost without selection; YCp is fairly stable but still episomal; YACs are large and can undergo rearrangements.
Common Pitfalls:
Equating high copy number with stability; higher copy often increases instability, not the reverse.
Final Answer:
YIp (yeast integrative plasmid)