Instrument order identification: which of the following is not a second-order instrument?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Bare mercury-in-glass thermometer

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The “order” of an instrument refers to the order of the differential equation describing its dynamic response. Many mechanical/thermal instruments behave as first- or second-order systems depending on construction details such as protective covers, wells, or multiple elastic elements.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • A bare mercury-in-glass thermometer has a single dominant thermal capacitance/resistance pair.
  • Adding coverings/wells introduces additional lags, often elevating the effective order.
  • Composite pressure devices with multiple elastic elements can behave as second order.


Concept / Approach:
A bare mercury-in-glass thermometer is classically modelled as a first-order system: one time constant dominates heat transfer from the fluid to the bulb and mercury. When a protective covering or thermowell is added, extra thermal resistance/capacitance can create effectively second-order behaviour. Complex pressure gauges with bellows/tank arrangements similarly produce second-order responses.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify the simplest configuration: bare mercury thermometer → first order.Recognise added layers/volumes → additional dynamics → second order.Select the instrument that is not second order: bare mercury-in-glass thermometer.


Verification / Alternative check:
Standard instrumentation texts model bare thermometers as first-order, adding a second lag for wells/covers.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Thermometer with covering — additional lag makes it second order.Bellows/tubes/tank gauge — multiple elastic/volume effects → second order.None of these — incorrect because at least one option (bare thermometer) is not second order.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming all thermometers behave identically regardless of mounting; installation affects instrument dynamics.


Final Answer:
Bare mercury-in-glass thermometer

More Questions from Process Control and Instrumentation

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion