Flow measurement – identify the device that is not a differential-pressure meter Which of the following is not a differential-pressure (DP) type flow meter?
-
ARotameter
-
BVenturimeter
-
CFlow nozzle
-
DOrificemeter
Answer
Correct Answer: Rotameter
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Industrial flow measurement devices come in many forms. Differential-pressure (DP) meters infer flow from a pressure drop created by a restriction. Variable-area meters (rotameters) infer flow from the equilibrium position of a float in a tapered tube. Recognizing the measurement principle is foundational in instrumentation selection and sizing.Given Data / Assumptions:
- DP meters: pressure drop across a primary element is related to flow (Bernoulli + discharge coefficient).
- Variable-area meter: float rises until drag force balances weight minus buoyancy.
- Ideal fluids and standard installation practices are assumed for principle identification.
Concept / Approach:Venturimeters, flow nozzles, and orificemeters are textbook DP meters. Each creates a constriction; the static pressure difference between upstream and throat/taps correlates with volumetric or mass flow after calibration. A rotameter, however, uses a tapered transparent tube and a float. The area available to flow increases with float height; the float's position (not a DP reading) is directly indicated and correlated to flow rate. Thus, the rotameter is not a DP meter.Step-by-Step Solution:
Group devices by principle: Venturi/nozzle/orifice → DP; rotameter → variable-area.Apply definition: DP meters measure pressure drop; rotameter measures float height.Select the non-DP device: rotameter.Verification / Alternative check:Standards (ISO/ASME) classify Venturi, nozzle, orifice under DP primary devices, while rotameters are listed under variable-area (VA) meters.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Venturimeter / Flow nozzle / Orificemeter: All operate on differential pressure across a constriction.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming every meter with a pressure effect is a DP meter; in rotameters the indicated variable is position, not measured pressure drop.
Final Answer:Rotameter