Cell Ultrastructure — Which two organelles most closely resemble each other in overall membrane architecture and cisternal/tubular organization?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Golgi apparatus and smooth endoplasmic reticulum (ER)

Explanation:


Introduction:
This question probes recognition of organelle morphology. While many organelles are membrane-bound, their shapes and organizations differ: sheets, tubules, stacks, or vesicles. Identifying which pair appears most similar requires recalling the cisternal/tubular nature of the endomembrane system.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Golgi apparatus consists of stacked, flattened cisternae with budding vesicles.
  • Smooth ER forms an interconnected network of tubules and cisternae.
  • Other options pair organelles with very different architectures.


Concept / Approach:
Focus on membrane topology and continuity. Golgi and smooth ER share sheet/tubule-like cisternal morphology and dynamic vesicular traffic within the endomembrane system, making them most alike visually and structurally at light/electron micrograph level.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1) Nucleus vs vesicle: nucleus has a double membrane and pores; vesicles are small single-membrane spheres.2) Golgi vs smooth ER: both comprise membrane cisternae and tubules; closest resemblance.3) Vacuole vs cytoskeleton: vacuole is a membrane sac; cytoskeleton is protein filaments with no membrane.4) Lysosome vs chloroplast: chloroplast is double-membraned with thylakoids; lysosome is a small single-membraned vesicle.5) Ribosome vs lysosome: ribosomes are ribonucleoprotein particles, not membrane-bound.


Verification / Alternative check:
Both Golgi and smooth ER continuously exchange membranes and cargo, reinforcing their architectural similarity within the same trafficking system.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

a) Very dissimilar envelope vs spherical vesicle.c) One is membrane-bound, the other is filamentous.d) Double-membraned plastid vs degradative vesicle.e) Non-membranous particle vs acidic vesicle.


Common Pitfalls:
Equating 'membrane-bound' with 'structurally alike' without considering envelopes, stacks, and network geometry.


Final Answer:
Golgi apparatus and smooth ER.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion