Toxin susceptibility testing: Which test historically indicated a patient’s cutaneous susceptibility to streptococcal pyrogenic (erythrogenic) exotoxin associated with scarlet fever?
-
ASchick test
-
BDisk test
-
CASO test
-
DPrecipitation test
Answer
Correct Answer: Disk test
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Before modern molecular diagnostics, toxin susceptibility tests were used to infer immunity to specific bacterial exotoxins. For streptococcal scarlet fever, a historical intradermal test assessed host sensitivity to pyrogenic (erythrogenic) exotoxin.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- “Schick test” evaluates diphtheria toxin susceptibility, not streptococcal exotoxin.
- ASO measures antibodies to streptolysin O, reflecting past infection, not toxin susceptibility.
- The item labeled “Disk test” refers to the classic “Dick test,” the historical skin test for susceptibility to streptococcal erythrogenic toxin.
Concept / Approach:
The Dick test involved intradermal injection of diluted streptococcal exotoxin with a control injection on the opposite arm. A local erythematous response indicated susceptibility; absence suggested neutralizing antibodies. Although obsolete, the concept distinguishes between toxin susceptibility testing and antibody titer assays.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Match each option to the correct organism/toxin context.Recognize Schick = diphtheria, ASO = past strep infection, precipitation test = general immunodiffusion/diverse uses.Identify “Disk/Dick test” as the test for streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxin susceptibility.Select “Disk test.”Verification / Alternative check:
Medical history texts document the Dick test use when scarlet fever was common. Positive skin reactions correlated with clinical susceptibility.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Schick test is specific to Corynebacterium diphtheriae toxin.
ASO does not test susceptibility; it detects antibodies post-infection.
“Precipitation test” is nonspecific and not the named historical assay for this toxin.
Common Pitfalls:
Confusing similar-sounding “Schick” and “Dick” tests; remember “Dick” for scarlet fever toxin, “Schick” for diphtheria toxin.
Final Answer:
Disk test