Collision vs broadcast domains: Which statement about what a switch and a router create is true in a default, non-VLAN Ethernet LAN?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: A switch creates separate collision domains but one broadcast domain. A router provides a separate broadcast domain.

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Designing Ethernet LANs requires distinguishing how switches and routers segment traffic. Switches break up collisions; routers break up broadcasts. This determines scalability and performance.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • No VLANs are configured; one VLAN, one broadcast domain across the switch.
  • Switch ports operate as individual collision domains.
  • Routers separate broadcast domains at Layer 3.


Concept / Approach:
Each switch port is its own collision domain; hence, a switch creates many collision domains but still one broadcast domain per VLAN. A router does not forward broadcasts between interfaces, thereby creating distinct broadcast domains on each interface/subnet.



Step-by-Step Solution:

Switch: multiple collision domains (per port) + one broadcast domain (per VLAN).Router: separates broadcast domains by subnets (no L2 broadcast forwarding).Match to answer set → option describing separate collisions for switch and separate broadcast domains via router.


Verification / Alternative check:
Simple lab: ARP broadcast will traverse all switch ports in a VLAN, but not pass through the router to another subnet.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Options claiming a switch creates multiple broadcast domains are wrong without VLANs. Options claiming a router creates only collision domains misunderstand L3 behavior.



Common Pitfalls:
Equating switch segmentation with broadcast segmentation; only VLANs or routers segment broadcasts.



Final Answer:
A switch creates separate collision domains but one broadcast domain. A router provides a separate broadcast domain.

More Questions from Spanning Tree Protocol

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion