STP convergence state: After a spanning-tree topology has converged, which statement accurately describes the state of switch/bridge ports?
-
AAll ports are in the forwarding state.
-
BAll ports are assigned as either root or designated ports.
-
CAll ports are in either the forwarding or blocking (alternate) state.
-
DAll ports are either blocking or looping.
-
EOnly edge ports forward; all others block.
Answer
Correct Answer: All ports are in either the forwarding or blocking (alternate) state.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Spanning Tree Protocol converges by selecting a root bridge and then determining which links forward and which must be blocked to prevent loops. Understanding the steady-state port roles and states is essential for troubleshooting and design.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Classic STP (802.1D) and RSTP (802.1w) converge to a loop-free tree.
- Ports have roles (root, designated, alternate/backup) and states (forwarding, blocking/discarding).
- Edge/PortFast ports transition rapidly but still obey loop-free principles.
Concept / Approach:In a converged topology, exactly enough ports forward to maintain connectivity; redundant paths are placed in a non-forwarding state (blocking in 802.1D, discarding in 802.1w). Therefore, every non-administratively-down port is either forwarding or blocked/discarding.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize that forwarding on all ports would create loops — impossible.Note roles: root and designated ports forward; non-designated (alternate/backup) block/discard.Select the statement that includes both forwarding and blocking states.Verification / Alternative check:show spanning-tree output displays port roles and states; you will observe a mix of forwarding and discarding states in redundant topologies.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- “All ports forwarding” is false in a redundant design.
- “All ports root or designated” ignores non-designated/alternate roles.
- “Blocking or looping” uses a nonstandard term; ports do not “loop.”
- “Only edge ports forward” is inaccurate; trunk/root/designated ports also forward.
Common Pitfalls:Equating roles with states; forgetting that RSTP uses “discarding” not “blocking,” though conceptually similar.
Final Answer:All ports are in either the forwarding or blocking (alternate) state.