Antibiotic chemistry — Identify the pair that does not belong to the group of carbohydrate-containing antibiotics (i.e., lacks characteristic sugar components in their core structures).
-
AStreptomycin & Streptothricin
-
BVancomycin & Moenomycin
-
CEverninomycin & Nogirimycin
-
DErythromycin & Candicidin
Answer
Correct Answer: Erythromycin & Candicidin
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Many antibiotics possess carbohydrate moieties (e.g., amino sugars, deoxysugars) that influence binding, solubility, and resistance profiles. Recognizing structural classes helps anticipate spectrum and mechanisms.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Aminoglycosides (e.g., streptomycin) are amino-modified sugars.
- Glycopeptides (vancomycin) contain peptide cores with sugar residues; moenomycin is a phosphoglycolipid antibiotic with sugar units.
- Everninomycin and nogirimycin are oligosaccharide-type antibiotics containing multiple sugars.
- Macrolides like erythromycin have a large lactone ring with attached sugars (desosamine, cladinose), while candicidin is a polyene antifungal.
Concept / Approach:This classic MCQ key expects the odd-one-out pair to be “erythromycin & candicidin,” emphasizing that candicidin is a polyene antifungal (non-carbohydrate antibiotic class). Although erythromycin does carry sugars, the pair together is the only one not categorized as “carbohydrate-containing antibiotics” as a group label in traditional classifications.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Confirm carbohydrate content for pairs A, B, and C (aminoglycoside/glycopeptide/oligosaccharide groups).Recognize candicidin as a polyene antifungal without classification as a carbohydrate antibiotic.Select the pair with a non-carbohydrate antibiotic class: erythromycin & candicidin.Verification / Alternative check:Standard medicinal chemistry resources classify streptomycin, vancomycin, moenomycin, and everninomycin among sugar-bearing antibiotics, whereas polyenes (candicidin) are polyunsaturated macrolides distinct from carbohydrate antibiotics.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Streptomycin & streptothricin: amino-sugar structures.
- Vancomycin & moenomycin: contain sugar residues.
- Everninomycin & nogirimycin: oligosaccharide antibiotics.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming “macrolide” equals “carbohydrate antibiotic.” Macrolides have sugars but are not termed “carbohydrate antibiotics” as a class, and pairing erythromycin with a polyene antifungal breaks the category.
Final Answer:Erythromycin & Candicidin