Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Solar power generated using photovoltaic panels
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Greenhouse gas emissions from energy production are one of the main drivers of climate change. Different sources of electricity, such as fossil fuels, nuclear power, and renewable sources like solar energy, vary greatly in the amount of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases they release over their full life cycle. This question tests your understanding of which source, among the given options, is associated with the lowest greenhouse gas emissions per unit of electricity generated, a key idea in environmental science and sustainable energy planning.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
Fossil fuel-based thermal power plants burn coal, oil, or natural gas to generate heat, which produces large amounts of carbon dioxide directly. Nuclear power plants do not emit carbon dioxide during the actual fission process, but their overall life cycle still involves emissions from mining, fuel processing, and construction. Solar photovoltaic systems convert sunlight directly into electricity without combustion, and although manufacturing panels emits some greenhouse gases, their operating emissions are extremely low. When life cycle analyses are compared, fossil fuels have the highest emissions, nuclear and renewables are far lower, and solar photovoltaics are typically among the very lowest per kilowatt-hour generated.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify that burning fossil fuels releases large amounts of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly into the atmosphere.
Step 2: Recall that nuclear power does not emit carbon dioxide during operation but requires mining and processing of uranium and large concrete structures, which contribute some emissions.
Step 3: Note that solar photovoltaic systems convert sunlight directly to electricity, with no fuel combustion and very low operating emissions.
Step 4: Compare life cycle studies, which consistently show fossil fuels at the top of the emissions range, nuclear and renewables at the low end.
Step 5: Recognise that among the options given, solar power generated using photovoltaic panels has the lowest greenhouse gas emissions per unit of electricity.
Verification / Alternative check:
Energy and climate reports frequently provide estimates of grams of carbon dioxide equivalent per kilowatt-hour for different technologies. Coal power is usually several hundred grams or more, gas is lower but still significant, while nuclear, wind, and solar are generally under 100 grams, often far below. Solar photovoltaics, in particular, have seen reductions in manufacturing emissions as technology has improved. Once installed, panels generate electricity for many years with almost no direct emissions. This confirms that solar energy is the cleanest choice among the listed options in terms of greenhouse gas emissions.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Fossil fuel-based thermal power from coal, oil, or natural gas is incorrect because it produces the highest greenhouse gas emissions of the options, due to direct combustion of carbon-rich fuels.
Nuclear power generated from uranium fuel in reactors has relatively low emissions compared to fossil fuels but still involves non-zero life cycle emissions from mining and construction, and it is not lower than modern solar photovoltaics in most analyses.
All of the above produce roughly the same greenhouse gas emissions is wrong because there are very large differences between fossil fuels and renewables like solar energy, and treating them as equal ignores well-established climate science.
Common Pitfalls:
A common misunderstanding is to assume that because nuclear power is low carbon during operation, it must be completely emission free or always lower than renewables. Another mistake is to focus only on the visible exhaust from a power plant chimney, ignoring emissions embedded in manufacturing and construction. Students may also confuse local pollution (such as particulate matter) with greenhouse gas emissions. A good rule is to remember that burning fossil fuels is always associated with high carbon emissions, while renewables like solar that do not rely on combustion have much lower life cycle greenhouse gas footprints.
Final Answer:
Among the given options, the energy source that generates the least greenhouse gases is Solar power generated using photovoltaic panels.
Discussion & Comments