VHDL vs. AHDL declaration semantics: The claim states “local signals are declared in a VARIABLE section placed between a SUBDESIGN section and the logic section.” Decide if this statement is accurate for VHDL (and clarify the AHDL distinction).

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Incorrect

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Hardware description languages differ in syntax and sectioning. VHDL uses entities and architectures with declarative regions, while Altera’s AHDL uses a SUBDESIGN/VARIABLE style. Confusing these can cause errors in tool flows and assessments.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Statement mentions VHDL and a “VARIABLE section” positioned between “SUBDESIGN” and logic.
  • VHDL entities/architectures do not include “SUBDESIGN.”
  • VHDL distinguishes signal vs. variable usage and scope.


Concept / Approach:
In VHDL, signals are declared in an architecture’s declarative region; variables are declared inside processes, procedures, or functions (or in protected types), not in a global “VARIABLE section” between named blocks called SUBDESIGN. The term SUBDESIGN and a dedicated VARIABLE section belong to AHDL, not VHDL.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify language markers: “SUBDESIGN/VARIABLE” → AHDL, not VHDL.Recall VHDL structure: entity (ports) + architecture (signals, components, constants).Variables in VHDL appear inside processes; signals appear in the architecture declarative part.Therefore, the claim about VHDL is inaccurate.


Verification / Alternative check:

Check any VHDL template: no SUBDESIGN section exists; signal declarations precede the begin keyword in the architecture.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Correct / True for both: Contradicted by VHDL syntax.Only true for SystemVerilog: SystemVerilog uses modules/interfaces; no SUBDESIGN/VARIABLE section.


Common Pitfalls:

Mixing vendor-specific AHDL examples with standard VHDL code.Treating variables and signals as interchangeable; they differ in assignment timing and scope.


Final Answer:

Incorrect

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion