Statement: Should there be repolling at stations where there has been both -capturing? Arguments: I. Yes, What else do you think? II. No, it is a wastage of resources.

if only argument I is strong
if only argument II is strong
if either I or II is strong
if neither I nor II is strong; and

Correct Answer: if neither I nor II is strong; and

Explanation:

I is not strong because it is a stupid argument. In fact, no reason is being given at all. II is not strong because ''wastage of resources'' cannot be arrived at absolutely; it must be seen in a context.

← Previous Question Next Question→

More Questions from Statement and Argument

Statement: Should the Knowledge of computers be made essential for employment in offices? Arguments: I. Yes, computers are state-of-the -art devices. II. No, works in office are yet to get fully computerised.
Statement: Should the monthly quota for liquor be raised by the Ministry of Defence? Arguments: I. Yes, troops will do anything if they are promised two things-liquor and leave. II. No, consumption of too much alcohol is a medical nightmare and leads to dependency.
Statement: Should the Government bring the prevention of Terrorism Ordinance (POTO)? Arguments: I. No, POTO endangers several constitutionally and internationally accepted human rights standards. II. Yes, terrorism has become a major threat and existing laws have proved insufficient to combat terrorism.
Statement: Should fixation of rents be a matter between landlords and tenants? Arguments : I. Yes, it is the sole right of landlords to fix rents according to his/her investment to carry livelihood and any intervention in this regard would violate Article 21 of the Constitution. II. No, this would increase the miseries of tenants because if landlords are give free hand they will start extorting money from their tenants.
Statement: Should there be two time Zones in India? Arguments: I. Yes, Britain, America and some other countries which have developed miraculously have two or more than two time zones. II. No, we have a big country like China where there is only one time Zone.
Statement: Should a person involved in an of terrorism in their own country be deprived form citizenship? Arguments : I. Yes, any act of terrorism is a speed- breaker for the progress of the economy of a country and this is against the definition of nationality. II. No, an act of terrorism is like any other illegal activity and for this the person should be treated according to the existing law.
Statement: Should education at all levels be offered in vernacular medium? Arguments: I. Yes, this is the only way to enhance the performance of the students. II. No, this will severely affect in acquiring of comprehensive Knowledge because of the lack of good books in vernacular languages.
Statement: Should the government allow use of LPG as a fuel for commercial vehicles? Arguments: I. No, when the petroleum agencies cannot fulfil the demand even for domestic use satisfactorily, how will they meet the demands for commercial vehicles? II. No, LPG fuel is not adaptable to the spark ignition engines and compressed ignition engines which are commonly used in the country.
Statement: Is the recent hike of about 50% in fees and transport charges by school in cities justified? Arguments : I. Yes, we have entered the era of information technology and inclusion of IT as a subject has put a burden of huge amount on schools due to expansion in infrastructure facilities. II. No, this will suddenly increase the burden of parents of the students.
Statement: Should commercial activity be permitted in residential areas? Arguments: I. No, these activities impair the growth of residents of residential area. II. Yes, commercial activity adds to adds to economic development, and it one of the major aspects of economic activity.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Join Discussion